Sunday, May 29, 2011

More about the Role of the Writer

The literary community often debates its relevance, debates whether reading/publishing/writing are dying. Are you surprised that writers can't agree that literature, that reading and writing ourselves and each other, is the essence of life? Of course, people do almost everything in life for metaphors. Not just writers, but all of us work, marry, live, and kill for metaphors.

It's always fascinated me that Islamic leaders issued a fatwa on an author of fiction, as opposed a writer of polemics or religious tracts. Though I've read many more articles announcing the irrelevance of fiction than its relevance, little was made of Rushdie's status as a mere novelist (as opposed to a theologian or politician, or writer of another form than novels.) That's because we know deeper down that fiction is relevant; people kill for Bibles and Korans. The Ayatollah realizes that the old metaphors cannot be supplanted except by new ones.

The new metaphors, topic of a future blog post.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

  3. As I was reading this I was thinking, could it be possible to intuit the need to insult some one that will proceed you?

    I'm visualizing Jonathan Swift's name on his grave being scratched out by Muslim extremest because of an insult buried in his fiction; and then the ultimate insult, having died centuries before the FatwaTards issue his fatwa. I wonder if he spoiled their virgins ?

  4. Also, Imagine a FatwaTard reading along, flipping a page and a sort of trap door to a sudden hell opens up and Satan blenches in his face. The ultimate personalized insult .

  5. Yea, I agree that fatwas are bad. And that fundamentalism, and organized religion basically suck. But I also agree with Blake that the imagination requires new metaphors if the old religions are fade. What will they be?